Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Could use advice re insurance settlement.


ST MARY'S, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 238
Date:
Could use advice re insurance settlement.
Permalink  
 


So, At the stage where insurance is settling on my car. Of course they are low on their offer.

The issue I'm having, I think is either the appraiser did not value the car correctly for its variant.

4-wheel drive BMW wagons tend to sell for more than their sedan counterpart. On kijiji at the moment there is only one vehicle 

like this one. My vintage BMW buddies in the USA have often successfully used current ads etc as a market condition. Is this something done here?

 

So, what are my options in negotiating. Have never had the (dis) pleasure. 



__________________


ONTARIO

Status: Offline
Posts: 751
Date:
Permalink  
 

I found 3 high valued vehicles same year and model as mine. They took the 3 and paid the middle asking price plus tax. I was happy. I printed off 3 from autotrader. They were happy with that. Hope that helps

__________________

E.L.T.A. ...................No Goofs !



ST MARY'S, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 238
Date:
Permalink  
 

GhostPost wrote:

I found 3 high valued vehicles same year and model as mine. They took the 3 and paid the middle asking price plus tax. I was happy. I printed off 3 from autotrader. They were happy with that. Hope that helps


 Sure does. :) This is exactly what I was doing.



__________________


NEWCASTLE, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 741
Date:
Permalink  
 

When a deer decided to run into my 2002 Buick Century 2 years ago the insurance company wrote it off. The cheque I received was based on a 2003's average value and they also added in the taxes I would be paying on that money for the replacement vehicle.

I was told this was an industry standard because the insurance companies had lost too many law suits for not covering the FULL cost of replacing the vehicle. It's worth a try to bring this up!

__________________


DUNDAS, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 1962
Date:
Permalink  
 

My experience is they will low ball you first  then ignore you for two or three weeks. they will send you a appraisal or quote from  401 auto that is just stupid. I just told them when we came to an impasse if they can replace it with a vehicle with the same or lower Ks and the same options do it. be ready for them to say the replacement has more options and try to get you to pay for them. Mine tried with the optional wheels which I quickly replied that I hate them and if you cant find another I will have to get rid of them myself. rather deal with crack heads then the lying scum I ran into. they lost big in the end but it was a fight all the way.



__________________
What a long strange trip its been


MILTON, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 982
Date:
Permalink  
 

If you are using comparisons for value get resale pricing from dealerships only if possible. They will usually sell for a higher price at a dealer as opposed to online pricing.

__________________

I DO WHAT THE LITTLE VOICES TELL ME TO DO.



BROCKVILLE, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 655
Date:
Permalink  
 

If your insurance company is paying for your replacement rental car tell them you're in no hurry to accept their offer until they get serious.

__________________


ST MARY'S, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 238
Date:
Permalink  
 

Thanks guys. Very helpful. Loss of use, they are paying for a rental...



__________________


CLINTON, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 3909
Date:
Permalink  
 

1.  Its my impression that they are always in a rush to get settled    

2. and its my impression, its your car until you SIGN OFF ownership

 

I agree with getting prices from High End dealers   BMW  Mercedes etc



__________________

 

 



HUNTSVILLE, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 175
Date:
Permalink  
 

and never release it from the storage yard until you are satisfied. Keep adding up the bill there too, between a rental and storage cost that can be $100+ a day......they will call you back quick.

__________________
Best defense is a good offense.


TORONTO, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 22
Date:
Permalink  
 

I just did this last year with my wife's car. Used up the entire amount of rental car as it is never unlimited, read the fine print of your insurance. I got an extra $500.00 with no effort but was unwilling to continue with them and waste my time for more. I got what I had into the car and I bought it back and parted it out as well and got another $1200.00 from that.

__________________


ST MARY'S, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 238
Date:
Permalink  
 

Playin Hookie wrote:

and never release it from the storage yard until you are satisfied. Keep adding up the bill there too, between a rental and storage cost that can be $100+ a day......they will call you back quick.


 Now this I didn't know, because there was a push to release it from the yard. :(

I see the game they play...



__________________


HUNTSVILLE, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 175
Date:
Permalink  
 

bmw2002e3 wrote:
Playin Hookie wrote:

and never release it from the storage yard until you are satisfied. Keep adding up the bill there too, between a rental and storage cost that can be $100+ a day......they will call you back quick.


 Now this I didn't know, because there was a push to release it from the yard. :(

I see the game they play...


 Exactly. Storage adds up very fast and they know it, no cap there.

 

Look at it this way, basically you are negotiating the sale of your vehicle to them. You wouldn't let anyone else take your car without paying for it at an agreed price, why let them?

The flip side is be reasonable and not too greedy.



__________________
Best defense is a good offense.


PORT HOPE, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 2403
Date:
Permalink  
 

Interesting way of looking at it. Ed

__________________

Any day with friends doin car stuff is a good day



DUNDAS, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 1962
Date:
Permalink  
 

Talked to the guy who owns a large recovery yard by Brantford the resting place of missing chevy trucks he had to of had 200 or so burnt out shells sitting in his yard. when ask why so many he replied he has to track down original owner to find out what insurance company paid out on them save a few up to make it worthwhile then sue them for cost. Even when you sign over the ownership on payout it's still in your name years latter and any recovery company will come after you first. As far as rentals go have a close look at your policy because most have a maximum limit on rental cars. Like the government these people only care if it cuts into their profits and when that happens they raise everyones rate and say you live in a high risk area. Basterds    



__________________
What a long strange trip its been


ORILLIA, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 19
Date:
Permalink  
 

Actually I do have something to say in this thread. I'm an independant insurance adjuster. I work mostly property and liability claims. I do fire investigations, and have done some stolen vehicle and fraud investigations also.

Some of the info above simply isn't true, and I don't have time to explain it all.

It is not a "game" they play. The ideal outcome of each claim is to be the same, to indemnify you for your loss. However not all adjusters are equal, nor is every claim the same.

If I wan't happy with the offer, I would do my own research. You must be able to justify, in other words document, your reasons for a higher settlement. Present an arguement which the adjuster can defend in his/her file to their superiors.

In auto claims you are dealing with "desk adjusters", meaning they never leave the office. They hire appraisers to inspect the vehicle and do the research. They are usually low paid, its kind of an entry level position. They do have to be accountable for the cheques they write, therefore documentation is everything. Send your own documentation to support what you are asking for, and be reasonable, and you should be successful. And be polite, they deal with tons of *******s each day and have learned how to ignore them.

__________________


SOUTH RIVER, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 1771
Date:
Permalink  
 

Wow.

Your comment of be polite???  I don't see that mentioned in the fine print of my policyconfuse 

But then again...... you have to be an attorney/paralegal to understand all the in's and outs.

Do our own research??? really? Shouldn't have to. Again.....we pay for this service and should get what we pay for.

I'm sure like everything else, there are people out to rip off insurance company's so on the flip side, would you agree........ that there are insurance company's that  are out to rip off customers??

Kinda why some feel like we have to beg.....to get the service/coverage we pay for.

I don't care that they choose to take the top money I pay for the "service" they provide and pay lesser wages or sub out there job to an entry level flunky????

No disrespect meant to you in any way. I have had some great experiences with some insurance company's and some horrific ones.

 Not always easy to be polite to an ******* insurance company/adjuster  who is dragging out a claim so you can no longer afford to fight or "justify" why they should pay you out a fair price. That they feel that they are in a position to "ignore" a claimant  is very comforting as well...... unfortunately, customer  does not have the same indulgence nor do I at my job and still expect to collect a pay check. 

But thanks for the educational post and taking the time to explain what you did.







-- Edited by janies dirty 37 on Saturday 1st of March 2014 09:08:29 PM

__________________

Janice



DUNDAS, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 1962
Date:
Permalink  
 

I know several people that have had the misfortune of having some type of disaster in their home and None have had any negative comments on the way things were handled. around here with auto at least it seems to be the norm. maybe most people don't understand anything about cars but sorry I not one of them.and if the adjuster isn't smart enough  to pick up on that its his problem. Polite or not if they think they going to stand there and tell me a bold face lie and I'm not going to call them on it they need to give Their head a shake .  To be honest the time's i've had to deal with them they would of came out way further ahead if they were just fair to start with. 



__________________
What a long strange trip its been


ORILLIA, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 19
Date:
Permalink  
 

Maybe I've offended some of you. I'm sorry.

I say be polite, because why wouldn't you? No it's not in your policy but if you start off thinking you're going to have a difficult time, you will. I say please and thankyou with everything, whether its my family or I'm ordering a coffee at Tim's. I get great service at Tim's, and believe it's because I'm polite.

You do have to do your own research, it is in the policy. It's your obligation to prove your loss. No one does. The company always hires appraisers, contractors etc to put a value to the claim but it really is up to the policy holder to provide it. You don't pay for them to do that, but they do. The only service you actually are paying for is to be financially reimbursed for your loss, that's also in your policy.

My point about the low paid entry level desk adjuster wasn't meant to belittle them or suggest you are getting lessor service. The point was supposed to be that it's an employee that has little to no experience dealing with people or knowledge of claims, and they have very little if any authority to make their own decision. They are not allowed to pay more than the appraisal shows. That's why it's important to show your own documentation. They absolutely can't make a larger payout without documentation to support it. Most likely they know nothing about your car, or any car. It's all just paper to them.

It definitely is not easy to smile at an ******* and be polite but you really have to rise above the situation and do it. They make notes in their computer of your conversation. If someone else looks at the file they can read the notes and see where the claim is at. They will record anything nasty you say, and I bet dollars to donuts they won't record the comments they make back to you. Don't provide them with any ammunition to say to their superior that you have been difficult to deal with. They can easily paint you to be an ******* and gain sympathy in the office for dealing with you. Their superior will have to approve any payment larger than their original appraisal.

You are at a real disadvantage with this. I agree it's not fair, and say not all will do that, but there are definitely some who do.

I've never been a desk adjuster. I work for 18 different companies, hired as needed. There are none I work for that ask me to do something unethical or to do what I did not think was fair. I wouldn't do it anyways, life is too short to compromise principles for money. I'd rather do something else for a living than not be able to sleep at night. I was a mechanical engineer, and hated it. I went back to school to learn this job. I wanted a job where I was helping people, and at the end of the day I believe I do. I have helped people restore their lives when there is coverage available. Being said I have had to deny claims for people in very unfortunate situations because the policy conditions were not met or there was no coverage for the incident that occurred.

I don't know how many companys are out there, maybe 1000, maybe 4000? I can't say how they all work. I would like to believe they all work fairly and honestly, because there are laws in place to enforce that, but the reality may be very different. It's really not hard to find someone with a horror story of an insurance claim.

I have met other many other adjusters in my local area that are great to deal with and several that are 100% complete dicks. Every profession has people that leave others with a very poor image of what the profession is, but we do seem to have our fair share human douchbags in this one.

__________________


ORILLIA, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 19
Date:
Permalink  
 

In the interest of being completely honest with you, I have given priority in the past to some customers over others. And I will do it again.

I try to treat all the same, and I do settle all claims fairly for what I can document and justify, but not everyone has agreed with me that their settlement is fair. I can't help that.

I can only call one person at a time, review one estimate at a time etc. When it comes to choices over who I respond to first, the 88 year old lady who lives alone and needs help will always get preference over the 20-something jerk who swears at me and refuses to help himself. Maybe not fair to the jerk, but in that situation I don't care.



__________________


PORT HOPE, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 2403
Date:
Permalink  
 

That is the same in most business.I will sometimes if really busy go to fix the familys stove over the guys dishwasher say,Doesn't make him happy but thats just the way it is.It is a question of need.People need to remember There are other people in this world and sometimes you are second in line and sometimes you are wrong in a matter.I would be a lot easier if the average person read what they were signing and actually listned to what was being said and not what they thought was said.The people you deal with during the day weather selling you a coffee or a car are just that people doing a job .A guy I used to work for once said something I think about all the time when dealing with customers ,Help the ones most in need first,help the ones that are fair and pay there bills on time next and leave the screemers till last as they probably can't get any madder than they are now.Think about your job if the first workorder on your desk or person thru the shop door or drive thru window or checkout counter is a screemer or the first guy you see at the factory is that pinhead manager and he is headed your way,how do you feel.Point is people are people and all should be treated like the golden rule says.If you didn't read the whole thing or ask questions when buying who is really at fault. Ed

__________________

Any day with friends doin car stuff is a good day



ST MARY'S, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 238
Date:
Permalink  
 

Thanks. That insight was very helpful. I suspected a few things you confirmed :)

__________________


BRADFORD, ONT

Status: Offline
Posts: 217
Date:
Permalink  
 

Go to a Service Ontario office (MTO) and get the value of your car that the Ontario Government would charge you tax on.
It's too late now but in the future place a higher value on Appraisals, agreed upon values, and non-depreciating value coverage. A few more $$ up front will amke a big difference down the road.

the Kid

__________________

In the words of Red Green "Remember, I'm pulling for you. We're all in this together".

Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.



Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard